A randomised trial by researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and Northeastern put 1,100 Google users into AI Mode for a week. Their clicks out to websites fell 18.8 percentage points against the control group, and they made 2.27 fewer clicks to outside sites a day.
This is the first controlled measurement of what AI Mode does to traffic, rather than another before and after chart. It is also a forced week on 1,100 American users, so read it as the shape of the risk if Google keeps moving searches into AI Mode, not as something happening to your traffic this month.
What happened
Researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and Northeastern ran a randomised trial on Google Search with 1,100 participants recruited in March 2026. A Chrome extension gave each group a different version of search for a week: one routed every search into AI Mode, one hid the AI entirely, and one left search alone. The group pushed into AI Mode clicked out to websites 18.8 percentage points less often than the control group, made 2.27 fewer clicks to outside sites a day, and were 11.2 points more likely to search on Bing, DuckDuckGo or Yahoo. The group with the AI removed clicked out 8.8 points more, though that figure needed adjusting because the extension stopped hiding AI Overviews partway through, and the unadjusted one was too small to call. Every participant was American, younger and better educated than the population, and the paper is a preprint from August that has not been peer reviewed.
What it means for you
AI Mode was 0.6% of these people's searches before the trial began, so nobody's traffic is falling by that much today. The trial shows what happens if Google keeps moving searches into AI Mode: clicks go down, the search takes slightly longer, and people rate it as less useful and trust it less. Paid clicks fell further, by 42.7 points, because AI Mode carried no ads while the trial ran.
What to do
- Split AI Mode and AI Overview traffic out in your reporting now, so you have a real before rather than a guess when the share grows.
- Judge the search work on enquiries and sales, not sessions. This trial counted clicks and says nothing about who went on to buy.
- Ask whoever runs your search work what share of your Google impressions already carry an AI answer.
arXiv
Real and worth watching, but nothing to act on yet.
You still rank. But Google's answering for you.
More signals
Get a focused review of how your business is found, where competitors win attention, and what to change to generate more of the right enquiries. You leave with a plan you can act on, whether we do the work that follows or not.
